So what we've decided on is Expected vs Unexpected Death, which is the better death for both the dying and the survivors. I'll just post the quick sketched outline I've been mulling over.
I. In literature, what depiction of death is more prevalent and more sympathetic and engrossing.
II. East of Eden by John Steinbeck (expected death)
A. Dying process of Samuel Hamilton
B. Funeral and aftermath for survivors
C. meaning of his death, how it reflects his life
III. The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald (sudden death)
A. Death of Jay Gatsby
B. Funeral and aftermath
C. meaning of his death, his legacy
IV. Which death is depicted as the better/more desirable/admirable. (I'm leaning towards the expected)
V. Conclusion, tying in how prevalent death is in literature and culture, even from a young age (Bambi, Charlotte's Web, Where the Red Fern Grows, etc.). Literature builds the expected death as the meaningful death, better for all.
Any thoughts you all have will be apprechiated. I am still trying to find a better example of the sudden death. The Great Gatsby works because he is murdered and there are a few pages describing his funeral. I am going to flip through Little Women to see if that can fit better so I'll see how that goes. See ya!